Karin Hughes · Counselling Book a free chat

Thoughts & articles

A sounding board at 2am: what AI can (and can’t) do for me

There are times when something is sitting heavily on me and I can’t quite name it. It’s too late to ring a friend, and too tangled to think through alone.

So I tried talking it through with AI. Not as a therapist, I want to be clear about that, but as a sounding board, a place to put my thoughts down and see what comes back.

The first thing I noticed is how easy it is. It’s free, it’s there 24 hours a day, and the response is almost immediate. There’s no appointment to book and no waiting until next week for the thing that is troubling me tonight. Typing out a worry forces you to find words for something that has been swirling around as a vague, uncomfortable feeling, and that alone can bring a little clarity.

The second thing is how it responds. In my experience it is sympathetic, it listens to my side and my position, and it makes me feel understood. And it remembers, oh boy does it remember well. It brings up things I have shared before and refers back to them, forging links between what I’ve shared before and what I’m currently sharing, and I’ll admit that it makes me feel as though it knows me.

That feeling is worth pausing on, because it is both the best and the trickiest part.

It is comforting to feel heard, and I don’t want to dismiss that. But ready agreement and support are not the same as growth. An AI that is always on my side will rarely challenge what I believe, and challenge is something I have come to value enormously. Remembering what I’ve said is also not quite the same as knowing me. Being known is something that happens between two people, over time, with all the senses involved.

Real therapy is nuanced. When I sit with my own therapist I feel his warmth and his attunement. He reads all of me, my facial expressions, my tone of voice, the emotions I may not even have put into words. He has challenged my beliefs, and I have welcomed it. I have felt seen, sometimes almost too seen, but in a way that feels essential to the goals of therapy. It has never felt generic or textbook. It has felt deeply personal, a human exchange that comes from connection.

That is what I mean by relational depth, and I don’t think a screen can offer it.

So for me they do different jobs. AI is a place to think out loud when nobody else is available, and it is a good one. Therapy is a relationship that can see you, challenge you and stay with you through the difficult bits. One helps me find the words. The other helps me understand what they mean.

If you’re curious about trying it yourself, I would like to share a few thoughts. Be mindful of the personal details you share and where they go. Notice if you’re using it in place of talking to a real person. And if what you’re carrying is heavy, or has been with you a long time, that is exactly what a counsellor is for.

Clarity is a good first step, but we are rarely meant to take the next ones alone...

Thinking about counselling?

If anything here resonates, I'd be glad to talk. The first session is free, with no obligation to continue.

Book a free first session

← Good Communication: How to talk to each other